Private investors are useless at longer term return projects.... only the state or state guarantees can provide infrastucture.
In this case... the state did get the ball rolling and private piggybacked as it always does... and then tries to say it did it all on its own.. as it always does. See also ... musk.
On a visit to Costa Rica last April, I was stunned by the number of Chinese cars on the gridlocked highways. My young driver and birding guide told me that Chinese car companies have made cars affordable for many more of his countrymen, thereby increasing the traffic. Besides the lower prices, the dealers also offer easy credit terms. We also saw two gigantic Chinese-made trucks at work on a road repair job, as well as a shiny new, big electric bus with an inscription describing it as a gift from the PRC.
It is worth recalling the story of Chinese common motorcycles in Africa. In a big market for affordable personal mobility, the Chinese at one stage were supposedly running some 150 models/brands there. Cheap, with quality issues, no service and reliable spares support, and no local manufacture/assembly. Not the best way to long term prospects. Enter the popular Indian brands like TVS, Bajaj, Hero who had decades of building road hardened machines…. with popular Japanese collaboration, before becoming their own. In what slowly turned out to be the world’s largest 2-wheeler market, India, they saw the African market. Entered with all correct steps….. hardened quality bikes, affordable, local assembly, reliable service and spares. Today, they appear to have eased out the Chinese products. The honest, long experience in the industry counted for them there. With dozens of models and brands, the history may be repeating for Chinese cars in fututre in world markets, though they have a stranglehold on batteries right now. Hopefully they will look into their 2-wheeler experience in Africa. Chinese explosion into this manufacturing business is less than 40 years old. The legacy matters.
It is true and not true. In China there are 2 state directed type of investments.
1 - Is the direct typical one. Subsidies, etc
2 - is the monetary one. The monetary policy of China is quite unique. They print money for dedicated sectors, and those sectors get credits far cheaper than the normal rates. Not passing through Chinese state budget, but across banks.
And then you have the private investment. Since the capital control stops any money going away they only places the private capital can do something is inside China.
Overall, the capital control and the sectors that they want to promove is direct consequence of the policies of the Chinese central bank.
Even if some regional government choose other champion it was Chinese system which make possible the rise of BYD and similars
People think China has a centralized economy. It does not. People need to read more books. This story has been well known for years. And BTW decentralization has its own set of problems.
Aside from the various social, economic, historical, and political takes on industrial policy in China....I've been to Shiyan, Hubei (in the mountains where all those industries relocated) several times; it's an interesting small city. Shiyan still has the Hubei University of Automotive Technology, a rather large and respected auto engineering university. It's also the headwaters of the South To North Water transfer project with the Danjiangkou Reservoir.
Private investors are useless at longer term return projects.... only the state or state guarantees can provide infrastucture.
In this case... the state did get the ball rolling and private piggybacked as it always does... and then tries to say it did it all on its own.. as it always does. See also ... musk.
On a visit to Costa Rica last April, I was stunned by the number of Chinese cars on the gridlocked highways. My young driver and birding guide told me that Chinese car companies have made cars affordable for many more of his countrymen, thereby increasing the traffic. Besides the lower prices, the dealers also offer easy credit terms. We also saw two gigantic Chinese-made trucks at work on a road repair job, as well as a shiny new, big electric bus with an inscription describing it as a gift from the PRC.
Sounds like American autos can't compete there.
Great work, thanks. This shakeout happened in computers and even the early car industry. Castle builders too, for all we know.
So, how does the Chinese state‘s strategy of car manufacturing compare to the industrial strategy of the US? I think the answer is obvious.
It is worth recalling the story of Chinese common motorcycles in Africa. In a big market for affordable personal mobility, the Chinese at one stage were supposedly running some 150 models/brands there. Cheap, with quality issues, no service and reliable spares support, and no local manufacture/assembly. Not the best way to long term prospects. Enter the popular Indian brands like TVS, Bajaj, Hero who had decades of building road hardened machines…. with popular Japanese collaboration, before becoming their own. In what slowly turned out to be the world’s largest 2-wheeler market, India, they saw the African market. Entered with all correct steps….. hardened quality bikes, affordable, local assembly, reliable service and spares. Today, they appear to have eased out the Chinese products. The honest, long experience in the industry counted for them there. With dozens of models and brands, the history may be repeating for Chinese cars in fututre in world markets, though they have a stranglehold on batteries right now. Hopefully they will look into their 2-wheeler experience in Africa. Chinese explosion into this manufacturing business is less than 40 years old. The legacy matters.
Reads like western sour grapes
It is true and not true. In China there are 2 state directed type of investments.
1 - Is the direct typical one. Subsidies, etc
2 - is the monetary one. The monetary policy of China is quite unique. They print money for dedicated sectors, and those sectors get credits far cheaper than the normal rates. Not passing through Chinese state budget, but across banks.
And then you have the private investment. Since the capital control stops any money going away they only places the private capital can do something is inside China.
Overall, the capital control and the sectors that they want to promove is direct consequence of the policies of the Chinese central bank.
Even if some regional government choose other champion it was Chinese system which make possible the rise of BYD and similars
People think China has a centralized economy. It does not. People need to read more books. This story has been well known for years. And BTW decentralization has its own set of problems.
Read Bogdonov's Red Star and you will find out why China does not care.
Bogdonov was a good friend of Lenin and wrote the book in 1908.
Also revisit the dictionary meaning of a strong economy and find the part where they mention currency. If you find it let me know.
Aside from the various social, economic, historical, and political takes on industrial policy in China....I've been to Shiyan, Hubei (in the mountains where all those industries relocated) several times; it's an interesting small city. Shiyan still has the Hubei University of Automotive Technology, a rather large and respected auto engineering university. It's also the headwaters of the South To North Water transfer project with the Danjiangkou Reservoir.
Good piece, thanks much.
Not exactly Murray Bookchin’s collectivist municiplism vision but it kinda rhymes.
Interesting mini history of Chinese industry and geography! And if the Simpsons was made in China it would be set in Wuhu not Springfield 🤔Doh 😁